Google Talk
Wednesday, August 24th, 2005Could this be it? The IM service that finally brings us a proper, unified IM platform we can all agree on?
For the longest time, IM has been a total mess. Incompatible networks with poorly written clients, corporations greedily denying cross-platform integration, Microsoft playing its usual tricks and sabotaging non-windows operability.
Open source networks were available, but I never really trusted them. Accordingly, I now have over 3 incompatible IM identities - one on AIM, for iChat, one on MSN, one on ICQ (and several old ones) - and we should include the one on Skype as well. I look forward to the day when I need only ONE IM identity, but I think it will be a long time before we see that.
MSN - this is the major force these days, with great momentum especially amongst less technical computer users. With very good integration between Hotmail and Microsoft’s “spaces” blog system, it will be extremely difficult to dislodge. However, many of its users are annoyed by the constant service blackouts, lack of compatibility, lack of ability to integrate with non-hotmail email, seeming inability to transfer a file quickly, and useless Mac client with no options to use a competing client. I think the best we can hope for is for Google Talk to reach a kind of critical mass such that MS feels obliged to at least provide bridged support to the Google network.
ICQ - this was the first and best IM service, before AOL bought it and wrecked it with ugly, bloated, gimmicky, ad-laden clients, lack of attention to severe spamming problems and general lack of effort to promote the system to new users.
AIM - hate it, never use it.
iChat - a very nice client for the mac, but suffering severe interoperability problems. Hopefully, however, it will be totally compatible with the new google system, instantly making iChat the client of choice for IM on the macintosh.
I look forward to seeing what kind effect of this new development will have on the general IM platform war.
.